Problems plague proposed horse trail

Joseph McKinney / How I See It
Published: March 24, 2008

A system of equestrian trails in the county would be very beneficial, particularly for local residents who enjoy riding. I'm not sure, however, that the issues associated with the proposed Culpeper Heritage Horse Trail are being accurately presented.

First, I'm doubtful that a horse trail would yield much economic benefit for the county. It is not realistic, in my view, to expect riders from outside the county to spend an afternoon on the trail, then travel into Culpeper for shopping and dinner. Driving on congested streets while towing a trailer is no fun, and many riders are reluctant to leave their horses unattended. I expect the typical visitor will ride, have a picnic, then go home.

Next, horse trails require maintenance. My wife and I used to live in Nokesville, and while there we belonged to the Battlefield Equestrian Society, which maintains the equestrian trails on the Manassas National Battlefield Park.

From experience, we know that the BES conducts frequent work parties, and spends thousands of dollars on gravel, wood chips, timber and concrete culverts. Moreover, the responsibilities of the BES and the National Park Service are spelled out by formal agreement. Such an agreement between the county and the Culpeper Horse Owners Association is needed before the trail is opened.

Finally, as noted by Saturday's letter "Equitable equine opportunities for all" and Wednesday's Harbury-Snogles column "Virginia is for horse lovers," there are a number of inconsiderate automobile drivers in our community.

Unfortunately, the Culpeper Heritage Trail follows paved and gravel roads for much of its length. In fact, the county acknowledges that the trail is "intended for advanced, more experienced riders who can comfortably control their horse under most conditions, including close proximity to automobile traffic." The county's potential liability, should an accident occur, is a real concern to me.

In the meantime, as the Board of Supervisors considers the Heritage Trail proposal, there are other opportunities for trail riding. Within easy driving distance, horseback riding is permitted on the Brandy Station battlefield, the Phelps Wildlife Management Area, Sky Meadow State Park, Shenandoah National Park, and the Manassas battlefield.

Additionally, numerous organizations - such as area fox hunts - offer trail rides on private property. Have fun!

Joseph McKinney is a self-described "yuppie fox hunter" from Brandy Station.